Special Order Decisions
Syllabus 5.4.3: When to Accept Below-Price Orders
The Strategic Question: A customer offers a bulk order at a price below your normal selling price. Your gut says "No!" But the numbers might say "Yes." This lesson reveals when special orders add value—and when they destroy it.
The Boardroom Brief
The Scenario
You manufacture premium coffee machines. Your normal price is $10 per unit. A hotel chain approaches you with an offer: they'll buy 1,000 units, but only at $6 each—a 40% discount.
Your sales director immediately rejects it: "We don't discount our premium brand!" But your finance director pauses: "Wait... let's run the numbers."
The Gut Reaction vs. The Math
Gut Reaction:
"A 40% discount destroys our brand value and we'll lose money!"
The Math:
If Variable Cost = $4, then Contribution per unit = $6 - $4 = $2
Total Contribution = $2 × 1,000 = $2,000 extra profit
Why This Matters (AO2: Application)
Special order decisions reveal a fundamental business truth: price is not the same as profitability. A "low" price can still generate positive contribution if it exceeds variable costs. But context determines everything—spare capacity, brand impact, and customer awareness all shift the decision.
The Three-Gate Framework (Summary)
Contribution
Price > Variable Cost?
Ensures positive margin
Capacity
Spare capacity exists?
Prevents opportunity cost
Confidentiality
Low leak risk?
Protects pricing structure
✓ ALL THREE GATES must pass for acceptance
Failing ANY gate = Reject the order (even if profitable in isolation)
Sign In to Keep Going
You've reached the end of the free preview. Sign in — and upgrade to Plus or Pro — to keep going with Business0960.
Full Access
Unlock all 180 lessons